Skip to Content

      The Next Game Has Already Started

      The Next Game Has Already Started

      By Jerry Penso, MD, MBA

      Health systems are playing two different games at once.

      The first is defending the current model, protecting the payment structures and revenue sources that have sustained hospitals for decades. The second is building something new underneath it, a physician enterprise and ambulatory care model that can stand on its own regardless of what happens to hospital-based revenue. Most systems are still built almost entirely for the first game. In my own conversations with health system leaders this year, I have increasingly heard a belief that the second game is where healthcare's real future lies.

      I recently spoke with a health system CEO who is rapidly building freestanding ambulatory surgery centers and deliberately pricing them outside hospital-based rates. His reasoning was direct: The pricing gap between hospital and outpatient settings will narrow substantially over the next three to five years, and he would rather build for where things are heading than defend where things have been. Several leaders I have spoken with this year have told me something similar.

      When I described that story to Abe Sutton, Director of the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services (CMS) Innovation Center and CMS Deputy Administrator, he confirmed, noting that he was aware of large hospital systems already executing similar strategies, visible in their own public financial filings.

      From there, our conversation turned to why so many health systems still default to their existing hospital footprint rather than matching capacity to where patient demand actually is. Sutton was clear about the underlying cause: "We have distorted incentive structures to drive delivery into more intensive forms and settings," citing the lack of site-neutral payments and the 340B program as prime examples.

      I take that to describe a basic capacity dynamic: Build more of a given kind of care setting, and it tends to get filled, whether or not it is the right site for the care being delivered. Sutton's own view of where this leads was direct: "The organizations that five years out look more successful will have created an effective strategy for meeting demand where it is, have the capacity to do so, and not overbuild or maintain capacity that is configured incorrectly or for a demand level that is not being sustained at reimbursement rates."

      On the specific question of integrating electronic health records, Sutton offered a concise view: "Having one clean system is a lot easier." Sutton was candid that this is hard to act on: "No one wants to switch out their EMR; no one wants to learn a new system."

      He described two different responses he has seen work. Some systems take on the challenge themselves and build toward best-in-class performance. Others recognize the need but conclude they cannot do it alone and choose a partner instead. "Both are appropriate responses," he said, "depending on your market position and what it is that you are focused on strategically.

      Here is my own synthesis of a broader theme running through our conversation. The old model rewarded activity: Deliver the service, bill for it, move on. The future will reward proof that the care delivered actually produced the intended outcome. That is a higher bar. Systems that treat it as the new baseline will be ahead.

      I asked Sutton how leaders should think about committing substantial resources to value-based care when so much of the current environment still runs on fee-for-service. He opened with a reframe: "I wouldn't think of it as a value-based care strategy. Think of it as a strategy." He continued: "Don't assume that what you knew was true two years ago is true today."

      I took that as a warning worth applying broadly, not only to value-based care. My own advice to AMGA members is that the strategic choices that made sense two years ago—how ambulatory care is priced, how physician compensation is structured, and how much is invested in data integration—are being tested by a payment landscape that is already moving. In my view, the leaders worth watching are the ones willing to reevaluate what they believed was settled and rebuild their underlying structure before the shift finally arrives.

      I used AI tools to help develop this article from our conversation transcript. The ideas, questions, interpretations, and advice in this piece, except where directly quoted, are mine and reflect my own opinion, not the views of Abe Sutton or CMS. Abe Sutton reviewed and approved this article. I am grateful for his candor and time.

      Jerry Penso, MD, MBA, is president and CEO at AMGA.

      Originally published on LinkedIn.

      Advertisement

      Get the latest on innovative healthcare leadership

      Have a strategy to share? Tell us your story!